Dog Obedience Training Never Guarantees A Perfect Dog






Dog Obedience Training Has Something Missing

Dog obedience training was seen as a fix it all for a couple I once visited in Canberra, Australia who were being bitten on a regular basis at home by their dog. They decided that the offending pooch needed training, so they started attending obedience classes. Their dog became the star pupil, winning all the prizes at competitions for his impressive repertoire. The wife became so good at the dog obedience training skills too that she became an obedience instructor – excellent…

They were still both getting bitten on a regular basis at home though…

A Testing Time

When I met the dog in question, he tested me with a simple approach; coming up to me without me calling him. What do most people do when a dog comes up to them? What do you think the owners of this individual would do? What do you think was the result? I paid no attention to him and he walked back to his bed, gave me an appraising look and lay back down in his bed. A few moments later, I called him to me. He opened one lazy eye, looked at me then stayed put. Less than a minute later, he got up, stretched while fixing his gaze directly at me and walked up to me.

What do most people do when a dog comes up to them? What do you think the owners of this individual would do? What do you think was the result? The game continued like this for a while; by the end of my visit, I had patted him a few times without getting bitten once he realised that I understood his game and would not fall for it.

Dogs Are Capable Of Learning All Kinds Of Clever Tasks And Tricks

I have worked with police dogs, guide dogs for the Blind and even a dog that was trained to help a wheelchair-bound human to live a more independent life by helping with household chores. In each case, the dogs have asked questions of me on a fundamental level that was far more important to them than the jobs they had.

Making My Nieces Happy

I live opposite a park which has a little playground – I am a bad gardener so the idea of having a big garden next door that someone else mows was a stroke of genius in my head. Anyway, when my nieces would visit, they wanted to play on the swings and slide et al. I would accompany them and make sure that they were safe (well, as safe as they could be with an uncle who would push the swings a little too hard – I wanted to see if I could get them to spin all the way around…). However, even though they were my responsibility, I would not tell them what they could play on unless I felt it was unsafe. My job here was to make them happy.

Dogs Believe They Are Responsible For Our Safety

The same principle explains why there are so many dogs that are super attentive and talented when attending obedience classes, yet they are a nightmare as soon as they leave the class or show ring. They are doing their best to make their people happy but ultimately they also believe that they are responsible for their human’s safety too. This responsibility leads to so many behaviour problems in the everyday world.

Don’t get me wrong; I am not saying that there is no place for obedience training. As long as lessons are fun and positive you can enjoy this kind of work. I see it as icing on the cake; you can make the cake look as fancy as you want, provided the cake is underneath, supporting the whole construction. Without a cake underneath, there is an empty space which means the slightest pressure can bring the whole thing crashing down.

A Dog Will Take Responsibility For The Family’s Safety If He Can’t Trust A Human In That Role

As a Dog Listener, I provide people with the recipe to make the cake. Once that is in place, you can ice away. Dogs will ask us questions everyday about the cake element, finding out which member of the family (if anyone) can be trusted to look after everyone. In the absence of a responsible human, the dog takes over this necessary role. Once you know how to show your dog that they can trust you, the pressure if off them and they can actually learn the icing part more easily.

Transforming Four Potential Guide Dogs

In some cases, the training that a dog receives – to work with the police or blind people – is not cheap. It would be a huge shame to waste all that money when the way to turn failure into success is as simple as having the cake underneath all that icing. I once helped four potential guide dogs transform from failures (one was even biting the handler) to three successful graduates. Even the biter became a family pet so I will count that as a quartet of wins…

Dog Obedience Training Is Complemented By The Dog Listening Method

The good news is that the two elements are not mutually exclusive. You can enjoy the icing with the support of the cake underneath. The Dog Listening method complements and improves the results of all other kinds of training – obedience, guide dog training, police work, sniffer dogs, armed forces roles, etc. – by showing the dog that they can ultimately look to their human companion for decisions. Once the harness is on a Guide dog, they are working to help their human stay safe. At all other times, it is not hard to show them that they can trust their person with everything else…

©Tony Knight 2020

Tony Knight
I have been a dog trainer for 20 years and I travel all over the world sharing my expertise with countless dog owners in a positive and fun way. As well as helping countless people in the flesh, my eBooks help even more to understand their dogs and to solve all kinds of problem behaviour. My style of teaching makes dog training easy to learn and people enjoy themselves as they do so. I am able to talk both directly to camera and in an interview style. I have created several eBooks covering different subjects such as breed issues and specific behaviour problems. I have also produced many audio books and contribute regularly to newsletters, blogs and online Q&A sessions. I have a good working relationship with numerous rescue organisations whom I have helped implement techniques to successfully rehabilitate and rehome countless dogs. I love public speaking and have been told on many occasions that my presentations are like a stand-up comedy show. I bring everyday dog behaviour problems to life and people learn while they laugh. I divide my time between living in France and Australia. I speak fluent French and run courses and classes all over Europe. My eBook "Think Like a Dog" is available via I have also written the foreword to the French-Canadian dog behaviour book "A l'Autre Bout de la Laisse" by Jacques Galipeau, as well as for the Swedish book "Det Goda Hundagarskapet" by Mervi Karki.
Share this


Can Dogs Eat Strawberries Or Are There Some Provisos?

Can Dogs Eat Strawberries Or Are Strawberries Bad For Dogs? Can dogs eat strawberries? And how about you - do you love strawberries? Does the...

Can Dogs Eat Blueberries? Don’t Give To Your Dog Until You Read This!

Can Dogs Eat Blueberries? Can dogs eat blueberries or are they toxic? Yes you bet they can though their are some risks you need to...

Hypoallergenic Dogs That Are Least Likely To Cause Allergy Attacks

Hypoallergenic Dogs Produce Less Dander Hypoallergenic dogs are the logical choice if you long for a canine companion but worry about it triggering an allergic...

Recent articles

More like this


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here